HBM Capacity Parity and Market Dynamics
HBM Capacity Parity and Market Dynamics
I'll start by finding the reports on Samsung's HBM capacity and the SK Hynix share move.
Conclusion: The reports do not say Samsung's HBM capacity will surpass SK hynix's. The capacity comparison points to parity in 2027. What the Hana Securities report (Nov 13) says Samsung may overtake is HBM revenue, while SK hynix keeps the lead in shipments. The Nov 21 selloff was attributed to a broader chip and AI sell-off, not to this report. For SK hynix, the risk is a narrowing pricing and mix edge rather than lost volume. The market is also repricing how long HBM-era margins last.
Data as of: Korea Exchange close on Friday, Nov 21, 2026 (the latest session before today, Nov 22, 2026). Driven's structured quote tool does not cover Korean listings, so share prices come from Korea Herald's report of the Korea Exchange close, not from a structured quote.
Share move
- SK hynix fell 5.92% to KRW 1,113,000, and Samsung fell 7.01% to KRW 183,100 (). The implied prior close for SK hynix is about KRW 1,183,036 ().
- Korea Herald attributes the drop to a Wall Street tech sell-off and AI-bubble concerns, with foreign and institutional investors net sellers. The article does not link the move to a capacity report.
What is known about the capacity comparison
- Hana Securities' Nov 13 report, as reported by Korea Economic TV, projects 2027 HBM shipments of about 4.9bn GB: SK hynix 47%, Samsung 41%, Micron 12%. It expects Samsung to lead on HBM revenue, mainly because of higher unit prices on HBM4 for Nvidia's Rubin, which uses 1c and 4nm base-die technology ().
- Monthly HBM wafer capacity is projected to reach 260k for both companies in 2027. That is up from SK hynix 200k and Samsung 190k in 2026 ().
- SK hynix growth:
- Samsung growth:
- Samsung adds capacity faster from a lower base, closing the gap to parity.
- Both companies are short of supply. Hyperscaler 2027 HBM demand is estimated at roughly 5.5bn GB against about 4.9bn GB of supply. A second summary of the same type of estimate puts demand at about 44bn Gb against 39.2bn Gb of supply (). The two sources use different totals, but both show a shortfall of roughly 10–12%.
- Contract positions differ. Samsung has long-term agreements with 10 major customers and reportedly sold out its 2027 HBM capacity. SK hynix has agreements with 14 customers and says DRAM and HBM are effectively sold out through 2029, including demand still under negotiation (Korea JoongAng Daily, via search).
How a shift in HBM supply could affect SK hynix
- Volume is not the threat; price and mix are. Hana's view is that SK hynix leads on shipments but may not raise prices much on its existing Nvidia long-term volume. Samsung's HBM4 pricing reflects its newer process content. If Samsung's revenue lead persists, the pricing premium is where SK hynix would lose ground.
- Parity removes SK hynix's capacity advantage. Its 2026 lead of 200k versus 190k disappears by 2027. Future advantage would depend on yield, qualification, and contract terms rather than wafer count.
- Supply wave in late 2027. New fabs from late 2027 would ease the shortage. Hana expects supply and demand to rebalance only after the second half of 2028, when all three makers' capacity ramps.
What this means for investor expectations
- Morgan Stanley's Nov 9 report cut its SK hynix target by to KRW 1,600,000 from KRW 2,600,000 (). Its Samsung target fell . Both stocks kept Overweight ratings.
- The cut came while the bank raised its 2027 operating profit forecast for SK hynix by 13%. The problem is 2028 onward: the bank cut SK hynix's 2029–2035 average operating-margin assumption from 53% to 28%, and it sees a possible 2028 earnings cliff. The bank moved its top pick to Samsung, citing HBM share recovery and non-memory earnings.
- The counterpoint is Goldman Sachs, which said on the same day that Korean chip stocks are oversold. Its price-to-book estimates are 1.23x for SK hynix and 1.21x for Samsung, against all-time lows of 0.8x and 0.83x (same Morgan Stanley coverage source).
- Expectations are shifting from "who has the most HBM" to "how durable are HBM margins after 2027." That makes SK hynix's position more about contract structure and margin durability than about capacity.
Analysis The capacity-surpass headline overstates the Hana report. The more accurate reading is that the two companies reach parity in 2027 capacity, Samsung may lead on 2027 HBM revenue through pricing, and SK hynix keeps the shipment lead. The Nov 21 drop reflects a broader AI-sentiment sell-off. The bear case for SK hynix is that its premium shrinks and that 2028 earnings are harder to underwrite. The bull case is that shortages persist into 2028 and that the 2027 forecast upgrades still stand. Key checks: whether Samsung's HBM4 price premium holds in 2027 contract negotiations, whether the roughly 5 GW of data-center projects delayed from 2028 to 2029 stay delayed, and whether the late-2027 fab supply wave arrives on schedule.
Sources
- Korea Herald, "Samsung, SK hynix tumble as analysts split on chip outlook," Nov 21, 2026
- Korea Economic TV (wowtv.co.kr), "Samsung to overtake SK hynix in HBM revenue next year," Nov 13, 2026, citing a Hana Securities report
- vlsi.kr, "Nvidia's Bar Is $108 Billion on November 17, and the 2027 HBM Crown Splits," Nov 14, 2026
- vlsi.kr, "Morgan Stanley Cuts SK hynix Target by 38%," citing ChosunBiz (Nov 10, 2026) and Money Today (Nov 10–11, 2026)
- Korea JoongAng Daily, "Record profits fail to shield Samsung, SK hynix stocks," Nov 1, 2026
- CHOSUNBIZ, "AI demand to reshape memory market," Nov 18, 2026 (TrendForce Korea roadshow)