review-trade-decisions
Diagnose stock trade decisions using only point-in-time information. TRIGGER when: user shares fills, prices, trade notes, or asks why a trade won/lost, if they sold too early, sized badly, or keep repeating mistakes. DO NOT USE for stock recommendations, valuation, screening, or backtesting without actual user trades.
Creator
Shay G
Created time
Jul 15, 2026
Last update
Jul 15, 2026
Version
V2
Usage
1 Install · 0 Runs
How it works
Review Trade Decisions
Review the quality of a user's decisions, not just the realized outcome. Prevent hindsight bias by judging each action from the information available at that time.
Select the review mode
- Single-trade review: Review one complete or ongoing position from first entry through current position or final exit.
- Decision review: Review one entry, add, trim, or exit decision.
- Pattern review: Review multiple trades to identify recurring process strengths and mistakes.
Do not turn an ongoing-trade review into an unsolicited buy/sell recommendation. If the user wants a current company thesis, use the appropriate company-analysis capability separately and label the boundary.
Load the relevant references
- Read
${SKILL_DIR}/references/point-in-time-evidence.mdbefore reconstructing what the user could have known. - Read
${SKILL_DIR}/references/decision-framework.mdfor the scorecard and decision/outcome matrix. - Read
${SKILL_DIR}/references/mistake-taxonomy.mdwhen tagging errors or reviewing multiple trades. - Read
${SKILL_DIR}/references/market-considerations.mdfor A-share, Hong Kong, and US market normalization. - Read
${SKILL_D
